book cover

Lord of the Flies

3.89 ± 0.45 out of 5 (95% CI) | 122 ratingsMedian: 4.00

Lord of the Flies is a 1954 novel by Nobel Prize–winning British author William Golding. The book focuses on a group of British boys stranded on an uninhabited island and their disastrous attempt to govern themselves. Themes include the tension between groupthink and individuality, between rational and emotional reactions, and between morality and immorality. The novel has been generally well received. It was named in the Modern Library 100 Best Novels, reaching number 41 on the editor's list, and 25 on the reader's list. In 2003 it was listed at number 70 on the BBC's The Big Read poll, and in 2005 Time magazine named it as one of the 100 best English-language novels from 1923 to 2005. Time also included the novel in its list of the 100 Best Young-Adult Books of All Time. Popular reading in schools, especially in the English-speaking world, a 2016 UK poll saw Lord of the Flies ranked third in the nation's favourite books from school. (From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_of_the_Flies)

Similar Books

book cover Redwallbook cover The Bad Beginningbook cover The Calculating Starsbook cover The Canterbury Talesbook cover Memoirs of a Geisha

Nancy goodreads | 5.0 out of 5

Lord of the Flies is one of the most disturbing books I've ever read. It was required high school reading and since then, I've read it four more times. It is as disturbing now as it was then. Using a group of innocent schoolboys stranded on an island, the author very realistically portrays human behavior in an environment where civilization no longer has meaning.

Valeriu Gherghel goodreads | 4.0 out of 5

Un roman despre o insulă pustie și o mînă de copii naufragiați. Cu siguranță o rescriere a lui Robinson Crusoe (1719) și a altor romane cu insule și eroi eșuați într-un ținut mai degrabă paradisiac (Insula de corali, Comoara din insulă, Insula misterioasă etc.).

Dar scopul lui William Golding a fost îndeosebi unul polemic. Romanul lui va dezminți sau / și va ilustra (pe o cale ocolită) postulatul lui Jean-Jacques Rousseau: „Omul este bun de la natură, dar societatea îl pervertește”. Observație: cînd ajung pe insulă, mulți dintre copiii lui Golding par deja pervertiți.

În Viața, staniile & uimitoarele aventuri ale lui Robinson Crusoe, marinar din York (1719), găsim un personaj foarte norocos (iresponsabil de norocos!), căruia totul îi iese din plin. Caprele se domesticesc singure și intră de bunăvoie în țarc, grîul, orzul, cerealele cresc spontan din pămîntul fertil: „Mare mi-a fost mirarea cînd am văzut vreo 10 sau 12 spice de orz”. Cînd eroul e plictisit, un papagal inteligent îi ține de urît. Natura sare, așadar, în sprijinul nesăbuitului. Pentru ca fericirea să-i fie deplină era nevoie de Vineri. Și iată că bunul Vineri aleargă spre Salvatorul lui. Și i se supune.

Împăratul muștelor narează povestea pe dos. Copiii intră rapid în conflict, se fac două tabere, „cei buni” (din ce în ce mai puțini, rămîn la sfîrșit Ralph și Piggy, apoi numai Ralph) și „cei răi” (tot mai numeroși, în frunte cu Jack Merridew). Frica trezește în copii cruzimea. Încep să creadă că insula e bîntuită de o fiară malefică. Vor s-o găsească și s-o vîneze. Firește că n-o vor ucide, fiara e doar o fantasmă a minții lor delirante. Îl vor ucide, în schimb, pe Simon, un băiat epileptic, obsedat de prezența Ei. În realitate, Fiara e fiecare dintre ei și toți la un loc. Asta mi-a amintit de parabola despre Simorg, regele păsărilor, rescrisă de Borges.

La sfîrșitul lecturii (menționez că puștanii sînt recuperați de pe insulă), mă întreb încă o dată: Omul este bun de la natură și numai societatea îl corupe? Sau: omul e rău / crud de la natură, iar societatea îl ajută (prin educație, religie, coerciție, dresaj, azil psihiatric etc.) să devină iubitor și milos? Nu îndrăznesc să propun un răspuns isteț. S-au făcut experimente (mă gîndesc la cel inițiat de Christina Maslach și Philip Zimbardo, în 1971, la Stanford University), s-au formulat ipoteze: psihologii mai au de lucru. Și totuși: am trăit cîndva o împrejurare, în care am văzut că pînă și cel mai puțin violent dintre muritori poate deveni (fără să vrea?) crud, nemilos, viclean. Răul poate fascina. Trezește plăceri...

P. S. Deși în cei 70 de ani care au trecut de la publicarea cărții, exegeții au identificat toate aluziile (și multe altele care n-au trecut niciodată prin mintea autorului), voi aminti că numele ebraic Belzebuth / Beelzebub / Baal-Zebub (zeul impostor din Ekron) se traduce prin „Împăratul muștelor”.

LauraKathryn librarything | 4.5 out of 5

Note: I have stated that this book is for mature readers only, and the same is true of this review. This book contains many heavy themes which I discuss in my review.

The Story.

When their plane is shot down by an enemy plane, a group of British schoolboys – most of them strangers to each other - find themselves stranded on an island. The only adult on the plane was the pilot, who is dead, so there are no grownups in the group; only several big boys – Ralph, Jack, Piggy, Roger, Simon, Robert – and a gaggle of “littluns”.

It’s the biggest, boldest adventure any of the boys has ever experienced – life in the wilds with real mountains to climb and forests to subdue. But as time progresses and jealousies flare, it becomes apparent that unless the boys are able to subdue themselves, the freakish howls in the nighttime will not be the most fearsome thing on the island.

They’ll be the savages…

Discussion.

I first heard of Lord of the Flies in 2008. It was inevitable - having just read The Coral Island I discovered in almost every review of that book a reference to this one. From my thirteen year old perspective, Lord of the Flies seemed to be an effrontery – a corruption of the happy lark that I found so fun and amusing in The Coral Island. I decided that Lord of the Flies would be banned from my reading list; never would I so offend R.M. Ballantyne as to read this improper version of his story!

As I grew older, I became more aware of the continuous struggle in show more literature between idealism and realism. I came to recognize that, while pleasant, The Coral Island was simply an idyllic story which (rather like The Mysterious Island) reflected none of the true agonies and raw emotions which would be aroused by complete isolation from civilization. I grew more curious. I purchased a copy of the book, still wondering. And finally, I broke down and read the thing.

I’m not going to engage in a continued comparison between the two books. As I’ve already said, you can hardly find a review of one that does not draw heavily from the other. It will be enough for my review to say that they follow much the same pattern of events while portraying a completely different version of “happy boyhood”.

As the story opens, the boys slowly trickle out of the forest and convene together in their first assembly. With the exception of some sniveling on the part of a few of the littluns (and the near-prophetic concern of Piggy), the reigning spirit is one of realized adventure. These boys feel that they are living out the stories they’ve always read about – Treasure Island and The Coral Island specifically. The world is bright and happy – the beach is under their bare feet, the mountains await their conquering stride, and mighty deeds of exploration are just an arm’s length away.

Ralph is elected as the group’s chief. Together, all of the boys collaborate in a governing assembly, deciding which projects are of importance and who should complete them. Basic rules are established and responsibilities are doled out amongst the boys. They are playing at being rulers of the island.

And that’s where the breakdown begins. Because to the boys, organization isn’t a matter of sanity or survival. It’s just another game. Assembling together and declaiming bold speeches is another fulfillment of fantasy and gives the boys feelings of power. They follow the assembly’s decisions, but only when they want to. When a boy tires of building huts, he throws in the towel and goes swimming or exploring instead. They don’t have the self-government to force themselves to behave by the rules but follow their impulses instead.

Ralph, Jack, Piggy, and Roger notice this pattern. But they respond to it in two different ways - Ralph and Piggy one way, and Jack and Roger the other. These two sets of boys are reflecting negatives of each other. Ralph and Jack are both natural leaders with the ability to inspire confidence and to mobilize their followers, while Piggy and Roger each serve as counselors to their chosen leader.

Ralph initially exhibits a tendency to care only for himself. But after he is appointed chief, he grows into this role and views himself as responsible for the success and safety of the colony. He clings to the necessity of maintaining a civilized order, even when it seems dispensable. His constant attention to keep the signal fire ablaze testifies to his realization that ultimately he and the boys are in need of rescue. As order begins to disintegrate, he recognizes and seeks to repair his weaknesses as a leader by accepting counsel from Piggy. Even as reality grows more nightmarish and he begins to lose sight of why it is important to be civilized, he desperately clings to the fact that it is important and that without civilization they will destroy themselves.

Jack, the only boy to challenge Ralph in the initial election, seems to also acknowledge the importance of order. But after his (witnessed) failure to stab a wild pig when it was within his power to do so, he develops an obsession with hunting – partly to void his previous faintheartedness, and partly because it corresponds to his deep-rooted desire for power over others. After Ralph publically reprimands Jack for hunting when he should have been tending the signal fire, (due to Jack’s neglect, a passing ship went unsignaled), Jack revolts against Ralph’s system of order. After all, what is the point of maintaining rules and systems when all that is needed to survive is food and drink? Jack promises that any boys who come to his side will be given their fill of meat and be allowed to idle and play as they please. Whereas Ralph allowed all of the boys to speak at his assembly and acted as a public servant, Jack makes autocratic decisions and demands his boys to walk behind him in procession, announcing his presence as though he was a king. Jack also paints his face with pigmented clay, delighting in the savage anonymity the mask gives him.

Piggy, although initially rejected by the older boys on account of his corpulence, eventually becomes Ralph’s trusted counselor. Sensitive alike to affection and rejection, Piggy has a comprehensive understanding of human nature and is the first to predict the dark twist which overtakes their group. His constant cry of “What would the grownups think?” indicates his disdain for the childish inability to reason through plans and control impulses exhibited by most of the group. As Ralph begins to forget why civilization is necessary, Piggy is the lone reminder and becomes prophetic in his evaluation of the situation. After Jack and Roger steal his glasses, leaving him nearly blind, Piggy refuses to knuckle under and instead insists on being led into their presence where he decries their actions, boldly showing them the end of their savagery.

Roger’s character is developed last out of the four and, as Jack contrasts Ralph, Roger contrasts Piggy. Whereas Jack reverted to savagery out of jealousy and anger, Roger seems to fall into it naturally. Whereas Jack’s cruelty is born of a desire to rule others, Roger exhibits the characteristics of a true sadist – he enjoys cruelty for its own sake. Although no one is equal to Jack in his kingdom, Roger comes the closest and is co-instigator with Jack in the final acts of cruelty which complete their return to savagery.

A running theme throughout the story is fear. Jack feels it when he first goes hunting – he has a feeling as though someone was watching him. The littluns feel it more violently in the form of nightmares and supposed glimpses of a beast. As the camp devolves into less and less order, the fear grows proportionately, until even a few of the older boys believe they have glimpsed the beast. This beast becomes the embodiment of their terror and when Jack becomes his own chief, he insists that his men leave the head of their catch on a pole as an offering to the beast. Simon comes across this head in a heat-induced rambling, and, in the moment which defines both the title and the theme of the book, names this rotting, fly-swarmed pig head as the Lord of the Flies. In Simon’s dehydrated state, he believes that the Lord of the Flies speaks to him and his statement is colossal.

“Fancy thinking the Beast was something you could hunt and kill!” Said the head. For a moment or two the forest and all the other dimly appreciated places echoed with the parody of laughter. “You knew, didn’t you? I’m part of you? Close, close, close! I’m the reason why it’s no go? Why things are what they are?” [pg. 143]

And here, the message of the story which was effectively demonstrated before is now properly stated. The Lord of the Flies, that rotting, putrid fearful drive, is not an outer force. It is an inner reality which, unhampered by social conventions or self government, dominates. Now, I do not know if William Golding was a Christian. But this is a Christian portrayal of human nature – man, on his own, may regulate his sinful urges, but he can never conquer them. Evil is not something that exists primarily out there – it is strongest in here. In the case of these boys, no restraining influence of society was present to curb their descent and they had not the maturity to govern themselves. Their decline was inevitable.

There is a concept that has emerged, disappeared, and reemerged countless times throughout the centuries. It is that of the noble savage – that man, unregulated by societal conventions, is there to be found at his freest and best. William Golding, whether intentionally or not, strikes a death blow to this concept. Certainly, outer rules never made a man better. But they provide incentive to hide and fight sinful urges. They prevent that sin from festering openly. And they help to teach a man to govern himself so that when he finds himself in ungoverned territory, he still acts upon principle rather than desire.

While Piggy and Ralph fight desperately to adhere to a form of civilization, Jack and Roger reject it utterly. But their descent does not end there, for the mere presence of civilization on the island acts as a condemnation to their lifestyle. It maddens and enrages them, so they began to launch attacks on Ralph and Piggy’s camp. The fire, kept aflame to signal a ship, represents an appeal to civilization for rescue, which rankles Jack’s band. They capture the fire and debase its noble purpose by using it to cook the meats which they then gorge upon. Piggy’s constant moral wisdom enrages them, so they lash out at him, stealing his glasses and rendering him helpless. In the end, although he represents no threat to their empire, they hunt down Ralph, because they cannot stand that even one example of what they ought to be should exist, casting silent judgment upon them.

Happily, just as they corner him on the beach, the rescue ship arrives. After the paranoiac atmosphere which prevailed, the commanding officer, rather than seeming like a return to reality, himself seems unreal. As he surveys the painted, bloodied boys he remarks with an appalling shallowness, “I should have thought that a pack of British boys – you’re all British, aren’t you? – would have been able to put up a better show than that.” [pg. 202]

All the boys can do, and all we the readers can do, is gape at this profoundly ignorant imperialism. As though national pride, or birth, or any other force short of redemption could hamper the ravages of sin. As though boys are somehow less human than men and less subject to overpowering emotions of greed, hatred, anger, jealously, and power. As though complete, ungoverned, unchosen isolation was idyllic. As though anywhere in the world there existed that thing called innocence.

“Ralph looked at him dumbly. For a moment he had a fleeting picture of the strange glamour that had once invested the beaches. But the island was scorched up like dead wood – Simon was dead – and Jack had… the tears began to flow and sobs shook him. He gave himself up to them now for the first time on the island; great, shuddering spasms of grief that seemed to wrench his whole body. His voice rose under the black smoke before the burning wreckage of the island; and infected by that emotion, the other little boys began to shake and sob too. And in the middle of them, with filthy body, matted hair, and unwiped nose, Ralph wept for the end of innocence, and darkness of man’s heart, and the fall through the air of the true, wise friend called Piggy.” [pg. 202]

Cautions.

I don’t see how anyone could read the above discussion and not grasp the fact that this book is driven by mature themes, but I’ll state it anyway. This book is not for the faint-hearted, weak-minded, or feeble-nerved. It is a fulfilling book, but not a comforting one. I personally feel strengthened by having read it, but would not recommend it for those much younger than myself. Man’s sinfulness, while easily contemplated in theological terms, is not as reassuring when specifically examined.

Apart from the obvious overarching theme of degeneration, only one other element stood out, and that was the violence which grew in proportion to the descent of Jack and his boys. While initially Jack was unable to man himself to stab a pig, he soon grew to delight in the hunt, and one hunting scene is depicted. The boys chase down a sow, stabbing her with knives and spears until one boy finally cuts her throat. In this scene, one of the boys stabs a spear into her posterior, which is referred to by a vulgar term.

Out of this love of the chase develops a mantra which the boys chant whenever they hunt – “Kill the beast! Cut his throat! Spill the blood!” [pg. 152] One night, after a successful hunt, the boys are chanting this around their fire when a figure crawls out of the forest. They do not realize that this is the boy, Simon, who has been missing, and in a frenzy of excitement kill him before they discover his identity. (They have been worked into a fervor of fear against “the beast” and believe that they have caught him.) They also kill Piggy in a fit of anger and are hunting Ralph when the rescue arrives.

Conclusion. A heavy, sober read which I would recommend to mature readers who are interested in studying the complexities of human nature. For those looking for “light” or “adventurous” reads, this book will probably be outside your zone of interest – and comfort.

Visit The Blithering Bookster to read more reviews!

www.blitheringbookster.com

Lyn goodreads | 4.0 out of 5

Years after I read this masterpiece, it is still chilling.

Golding spins a yarn that could have been told centuries ago, primal human nature unmoored from civilization does not take long to break away and devolve into a feral thing.

As good today, and as haunting, as it was when it was published in 1954. This should be on a list of books that must be read.

** 2018 addendum - it is a testament to great literature that a reader recalls the work years later and this is a book about which I frequently think.

AidanCoffey librarything | 4.0 out of 5

Is mankind inherently good or evil? This question has been debated by philosophers and psychologists for many centuries, but it has no decisive answer. William Golding does an excellent job of framing this question in the life and death struggle between a group of choir boys lost on a deserted island. Golding crafts a narrative depicting the countenances of several children, whom he develops into several dynamic characters. What is fantastic about the characters in this novel is that each is relatable. Ralph, a natural leader whom the boys respect for much of the book, is the likable fellow we all know. Jack, a passionate and power hungry competitor to Ralph, can be interpreted as an athletic arrogant boy. Piggy, an asthmatic overweight intelligent boy, is the nerdy boy whom the group cruelly ostracizes. Simon, the dreamer; Roger, the sadistic tormenting bully; and Sam'n'Eric, the two twins who stick together in all activities are all relatable to people in everyday life.

Another special aspect of Lord of the Flies is its heavy use of symbolism. Nearly every object and idea on the island is a symbol, from the conch that unites them, to Piggy's glasses that start fires, to the fires that disperse hope in the boys' hearts. Each aspect of the story relates to the wider picture: society erupts no matter who governs it.

Which brings a final point to mind that makes this story special. There is a great power struggle between Ralph and Jack, which reveals the true flaws of show more human political thought. By seeming stronger and bolder, Jack attracts more followers. When Jack guarantees the boys protection, he can then convince them to do atrocious crimes. By winning over the boys, Jack demonstrates the policies of a tyrant.

Though William Golding intended this book to be a silly little tale about boys on an island, and though it can be interpreted and enjoyed as so, it is truly a brilliant allegory that can consul a depressed soul that it is natural for society to plunge into turmoil. So are you still not sure if humans are inherently good or evil? Read the book, and find out,