book cover

The Calculating Stars

3.90 ± 0.36 out of 5 (95% CI) | 124 ratingsMedian: 4.00

On a cold spring night in 1952, a huge meteorite fell to Earth and obliterated much of the east coast of the United States, including Washington, DC. The ensuing climate cataclysm will soon render Earth inhospitable for humanity, as the last such meteorite did for the dinosaurs. This looming threat calls for a radically accelerated effort to colonize space, and requires a much larger share of humanity to take part in the process. Elma York's experience as a WASP pilot and mathematician earns her a place in the International Aerospace Coalition's attempts to put man on the moon, as a computer. But with so many skilled and experience women pilots and scientists involved with the program, it doesn't take long before Elma begins to wonder why they can't go into space, too. Elma's drive to become the first Lady Astronaut is so strong that even the most dearly held conventions of society may not stand a chance against her. This description comes from the publisher.

Similar Books

book cover The Bad Beginningbook cover Lord of the Fliesbook cover Redwallbook cover Children of Blood and Bonebook cover Babel

Pezski librarything | 5.0 out of 5

The first volume of the Lady Astronaut series is not quite what I had expected. I knew it was an alternate history where women become astronauts far earlier in the process than had been the case in our reality, and the space programme is accelerated, but the inciting incident that causes this a huge meteorite wiping out the North American East Coast and instigating a few years of 'nuclear winter' followed by rapid and unstoppable global warming came as a complete surprise to me.

Kowal constructs the world perfectly, and draws her characters with skill, empathy and a startling attention to detail. The relationships between them - all from the POV of physicist and mathematician Dr Elma York - working as a 'computer' in the Space Administration; her bonds with her husband and her brother, the strength of friendships and rivalry with her fellow workers, and enmities with others, these really flesh out the details as well as all driving the book forward as much as the superb plot.

It follows in the tradition of [b:The Kinsman Saga|267331|The Kinsman Saga|Ben Bova|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1388458694l/267331._SY75_.jpg|1657367] and [b:Voyage|843565|Voyage (NASA Trilogy, #1)|Stephen Baxter|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1295247466l/843565._SY75_.jpg|55352] (with [b:Hidden Figures|25953369|Hidden Figures|Margot Lee show more Shetterly|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1481844518l/25953369._SY75_.jpg|45855800] thrown in - and I note that my editions cover and the movie tie-in of that latter book are rather similar! - and is probably better written than either of those earlier novels.

I've already bought the next volume and don't think it will remain unread for long.

Heather Reads Books goodreads | 1.0 out of 5

I haven't been this disappointed by a book in a long time. I should learn not to get my hopes up so high, but this one really pulled the wool over my eyes. It is a continuation of a story I did like: I read the short story (called "novelette") of Kowal's featuring the main character, Elma York. It's a simple but well-written story, and I considered Elma to have both heart and gumption. I liked her a lot. The story won a Hugo award, which is pretty notable.

So when I heard this novel was being published to tell the prequel story of how Elma York, the first Lady Astronaut, helped colonize Mars, I was here for it. 1950s Cold War era alternate timeline? A reimagining of the space race from a female perspective, in which a plucky heroine tears down prejudices and stereotypes? Cool, smart references to Ray Bradbury, one of my favorite authors? Real science in my science fiction? Yes, yes, yes, and YES. My body is so ready.

Did the book deliver on any of these things?

Not really. And in a rather cruel fake out, too, because the first one hundred pages or so is quite engaging. The depiction of Elma as a young married woman trying to get her life together in the post-World War II period only to have to grapple with a large scale disaster like the meteor strike rang quite true. I appreciated that she had bucked tradition and flew planes to aid the war effort. I appreciated that her background was Jewish, so that she would understand what it was like to come from a marginalized community. I thought it was interesting for her to discover that the rescue efforts by the government were divided along racial lines, and that she cared enough to do something about it. All of this is good stuff, often overlooked in fiction, which feels more important than ever to explore in our current tumultuous times.

After a time-skip, however, it's like the author decided to drop her own meteor on the narrative. It is difficult to encompass just how spectacularly this novel falls apart, but I must attempt to count the ways.

Characters. I realized halfway through there were either no characters I felt like I knew - or if I did know them, I didn't like them. Obviously we are with Elma the entire time, but she became insufferable so fast. What came off as a world-weary snark in the original story turned into self-absorbed arrogance and incomprehensible mood swings. She also had a strangely privileged background: despite growing up in Depression era 1930s as a girl in a Jewish minority community in the south, she somehow possesses a mathematical genius that allowed her to attend college in her early teens and earn a PhD in mathematics. .... Sure. And then during the war she was able to fly planes and avoid sexual harassment of other officers because she was the daughter of a general. Okay. Handy. Never mind that this novel is unapologetically set up to be about underdogs prevailing, as it states on the back cover: "Elma's drive to become the first Lady Astronaut is so strong that even the most dearly held conventions of society may not stand a chance against her." Because of this, I found the incredible advantages she starts out with to be a strange narrative choice, to say the least. And she only stumbles from there.

The other most frequently seen character is her husband, Nathaniel. Again, I liked him at first, but soon his role as the Most Understanding Husband in the World grew wearisome. At every turn, Nathaniel knows exactly what to say! He's dedicated to the success of his wife's career, even though it's 1952! He's so compassionate! He never blames Elma, even when she is so out of it she forgets to pay the electric bill and their power is shut off! How did she find this AMAZING catch of a man? The book never tells us. I kept waiting for some memory of a meet cute, a wartime love story against all odds, but it never happens... though we do get a few out of place harlequin romance-esque sex scenes. So that was disappointing, as was the inhuman ability for Nathaniel to avoid any potential conflict between him and Elma even when she vomits all over his office from nerves and he thinks she's pregnant. But when it turns out she's not, he's super cool about it. I kept waiting for some discussion of having a family, since, you know, it's the fifties, but nada.

Everyone else in the book is barely more than a caricature of the worst variety: we get a (usually non-American) name, a mention of what makes them part of a marginalized group, and a sole defining quality of their character has something to do with said marginalized group. The Asian character has stilted English. The Arab character has to stick to Muslim prayer times in the rocket-ship. The French character speaks French. Women of all stripes complain about the men who are always groping them in the workplace. The disabled character talks about his disability. The Jews talk about their religion. I know this was some attempt by the author to show diversity and inclusivity, but these ensemble characters are so poorly drawn the effect is ironic: reducing these people to the one thing that makes them the "other" instead of taking pains to draw them as complex human beings reinforces the stereotype. You can't just stuff your book with exotic names and achieve proper representation.

World-building woes. One of the things I was really interested in with this premise was the alternate history aspect. How would the post-war Cold War era progress with some sort of catastrophic event decimating the US, with repercussions felt around the world? Would it ratchet up tensions between America and the Soviet Union? What would the space race look like if it was to Mars to live, not just the moon to say we can? What about the very real climatic changes the earth would be undergoing as it was slowly dying? What about decolonization? Western democracy versus Communism? The nuclear arms race? So much was happening at the time on the world's stage and I couldn't wait to see how it played a role.

Boy, was I disappointed. I realized by the end I had no idea what had happened in most of the United States, let alone around the world. There is a vague mention of the former Soviet Union (when did it collapse? Why?), what sounds like the beginning of the Algerian war, and local food riots, and Communist China also having a space program, but the characters don't really react to any of these events. (It is revealed in the "historical note" in the back that the author pulled most of the news stories that start each chapter from real newspapers, and these provided most of what I understood about what was going on in the world, and they were largely divorced from anything the characters interacted with, much to my confusion when I was reading. This makes me suspect maybe she plopped these in after the fact to try to simulate current events without having to write them into the narrative herself.) The space program is somehow hiring a number of foreigners, but there's no explanation of why or how.

Worse, despite predictions in the first part of the novel that the earth would soon become uninhabitable, there is no real indication of hard times in the characters' periphery, nothing to put the pressure on to solve problems and get those people to Mars. There was even a section where some one-off characters posit that the notion that the earth was warming as a result of the meteor that destroyed the eastern seaboard and killed millions of people and displaced millions more was a hoax. Reader, I get the wink and the nod, but I would think this was a harder event to deny than gradual climate change.

Pacing and plot. This is where the book really started to get counter-intuitive. It is a not-short 400+ pages, and it has a second book. That's fine. There's a lot of time to cover here. Decades, really. But things go glacially. For instance, I really figured we'd get to Mars by the end of the book. Spoilers, we do not. Elma doesn't even break atmo until the last sentence. Then, instead of the plot being taken up by high-stakes situations, like how to make a foreign planet hospitable for longterm human life while people are slowly choking to death outside by the bad air and starving from world-wide crop failures, what is the main obstacle for Elma? Is it institutional sexism that keeps her from the space program even though she is clearly the most qualified for the job? Is it the crushing societal expectations coupled with social pressure and ostracism trying to force her into a domestic life she doesn't want nor need?

Nope.

It's stage fright.

That's right. She can do Einstein-level math in her head, avoided German bombers in WWII, but she just can't talk in front of a crowd. She throws up every time, because some boys were mean to her in school I guess?

This is literally the main conflict of the book. It's not Elma against a broken system, or humanity against all odds. It's Elma against herself, and it's baffling because it seems to be the exact thing that would feed the misconception that women are too emotional to go into space. I found myself thinking she did seem too emotional to go into space! What if she has a panic attack while trying to do some maneuver that got the rest of the crew killed and the bajillion dollar rocket destroyed? How far would that set the program back while the rest of humanity was at stake?

Then, the solution comes up quickly with a ham-fisted "it's okay to ask for help" message and some anxiety pills seem to give her an immediate cure all. Never mind that I'm pretty sure most medication for nervous disorders back then knocked you off your feet and/or were highly addictive. Surely Elma is space-worthy now!

I could keep going, because plenty more happens that defies explanation, but I'm tired. I'm especially tired of books that try to shove modern day agendas into period pieces. I'm certainly for more nuanced discussions of mental health issues, but reducing Elma's struggles to some minor and frankly first-world problems is a kick in the teeth to anyone who weathered real persecution and forged a path to progress through social activism. This book, despite its promising premise, betrays a shallow understanding of these historical struggles on almost every level.

Needless to say, I'm skipping the sequel.

rabbitprincess librarything | 5.0 out of 5

In 1952, a meteorite hitting the Atlantic Ocean and obliterating much of the U.S. Eastern seaboard. The Earth will soon become uninhabitable—and unless humanity wants to go the way of the dinosaurs, the space program is going to have to start looking at colonizing other planets. Elma York, one of the computers at the International Aerospace Coalition, is a trained pilot and served with the women’s air corps in the war. There are a lot of women who are capable of going into space—so why are only men being asked to join the program? Why can’t Elma be the first female astronaut?

I LOVED this book. It felt really plausible as an alternate history. The newspaper articles that began each chapter are based heavily on articles from the actual 1950s (sometimes with slight tweaking to accommodate the story being told here), and there was a good mix of characters. The pilot talk and the space talk were very well done; Kowal had an actual pilot write some of the dialogue with the control tower, and someone else checked her space lingo to make sure she wasn’t using shuttle-era terminology in an Apollo-era storyline (also, I only JUST noticed how clever it was that she named the spaceships in her story the Artemis class).

This book is highly recommended if you liked Hidden Figures, stories of women in traditionally male disciplines, stories about aviation (such as the works of Nevil Shute), and/or stories set in the 1950s.

Boostamonte Halvorsen goodreads | 2.0 out of 5

This book was okay. Nothing amazing though. Here's why:

I've read something like this, and it was better. It was different, but the overall premise is the same. I point you toward Neal Stephenson's Seveneves. His book is so much better than this one. Yes, I agree that they are different in a lot of ways, but fundamentally, they are about saving the human race as the planet dies, with women being the key to the success.

Mary's book empowers women, and I get that that is a primary focus...but I feel like she let it get in the way of the central conflict: getting a space program into space and saving the human race. I felt at times that the "men vs. women" conflict got in the way, like a big fly crawling around on the TV screen. I don't mean to diminish the conflict, or the historical accuracy of the battle for women's rights and respect; but I wish it would have been handled differently. I wish she would have done it like Neal Stephenson did it. Subtle background conflict that comes to a head in a marvelous way that makes women as powerful as they really are--where men and women both drop the book and stand and yell, "FUCK YES! THESE WOMEN ARE BADASS!"

I guess I can put it this way: The world is ending because of Climate Change, and we are given a 10 year window to fix it...but instead, we spend 8 years fighting about how women caused Climate change and visa versa. During those 8 years, Climate Change isn't really talked about. It feels like this:

"It's 120 in Vegas today, how is the progress on the Climinator going?"

"It's going alright, but James keeps messing with the mathematics because he doesn't like my equations because I'm a woman."

"Oh, well we need to get the Climanator going."

"Oh I know, I just really hate that James won't let me do math the way I want to because I am a woman."

"Well what are you going to do about it?"

"Probably complain to my husband, who will then have really awkward sex with me to ease my tension, then meet with the girls at the bowling alley and come up with a way to defeat James."

"Ah, well, we do need to get the Climanator going one of these days."

"Yeah...but James..."

All of that just got too distracting for me. And the awkward sex scenes....they were horrible.

I guess this novel just felt like she was forcing too much together, and it didn't feel natural to me.

I hate that I didn't love it, or like it more than I did...or...didn't.

skipstern librarything | 4.0 out of 5

This novel won a Hugo and a Nebula award. It's 1952, and a meteorite lands in the Chesapeake Bay, destroying Washington DC, and leading to cataclysmic change. Quality alternate history. Sort of a combination of TV show Designated Survivor, Ashfall and Hidden Figures. Elma York is an ex-WASP pilot and a human computer in the space program, and helps figure out that the Earth is doomed. Eventually, politicians are convinced this was not an attack by the Soviet Union, and the International Aerospace Coalition is formed to get humanity into space. Elma wants to be an astronaut, but only men are allowed. Elma is a fighter, has to overcome her own personal issues, and works all the angles to realize her dream, making a key connection that saves astronaut lives.