
Similar Books
carol. goodreads | 3.0 out of 5
Can a city have a personality? I think so. Certainly the feel of Los Angeles is entirely different from NYC, and different again from Chicago, right? But what are the components to a city's character? Despite being the centerpiece of the novel, The City and the City never came alive for me. Half the time I felt as if I was reading a dusty encyclopedia description of a city and half the time an oddly paced but elaborate mystery.
The story begins typical for the detective-mystery genre: we follow Inspector Tyador Borlu of the Extreme Crime Squad to the scene of a murdered and nude woman. It is a seedy, run-down area full of addicts, and at first it appears as if she's another lost soul from the streets. Tyador commanders an eager young subordinate, Corwi, for her street contacts and legwork. Before long, an anonymous tip points them in the direction of Il Qoma, the city that lives within/alongside/interstices with their own city of Beszel. The citizens of both places are monitored by Breach, a mysterious authority who will spirit away those who mistakenly acknowledge the partner city without following proper channels.
"'Why were you there?'
'... It was a conference. 'Policing Split Cities.' They had sessions on Budapest and Jerusalem and Berline, and Beszel and Ul Quoma.'
'Fuck!'
'I know, I know. That's what we said at the time. Totally missing the point.'
'Split cities? I'm surprised the acad let you go.'"
The idea of two cities, co-existing in shared spaces but actually separate nations, is a brilliant idea. Unfortunately, Big Idea is all that holds this story together, which has little to humanize it amidst a slow and painful investigation. It occurred to me that this is the premise of so many other books, the unseen co-existing with the seen, but I felt it was hard to get a grip on the intricacies of the schism.
Bezel and Il Quoma never truly differentiated for me. I think part of the reason is that Mieille relies on two main modes of describing his cities: the architecture and the political history. I felt very much like I was being given a lesson on Yugoslavia, or walled-Berlin, or one of the split cities so overtly mentioned. An example from page 43:
"In typical political cliche, unificationists were split on many axes. Some groups were illegal, sister-organisations in both Beszel and Ul Qoma. The banned had at varioius points in their history advocated the use of violence to bring the cities to their God-, destiny-, history-, or people-intended unity. Some had, mostly cack-handedly, targeted nationalist intellectuals--bricks through windows and shit through doors. They had been accused of furtively propagandising among refugees and new immigrants with limited expertise at seeing and unseeing, at being in one particular city. The activists wanted to weaponise such urban uncertainty."
I can appreciate such description, but does it resonate? Evoke emotion? I think of Kate Griffin's Matthew Swift series, how London comes alive with the lyrical descriptions, and wonder at the difference. Perhaps people would have helped, or further character-building of the ones we had. Histories of the characters could have been used to gain more insight into the schism between the two, but only Tyador's youth is shared in any detail. About the only person that stood out for me was the detective's superior, who humorously managed to undercut Borlu's complaints with every line of dialogue.
"'This is bullshit. We've been screwed.'
'It is bullshit, he tells me,' Gadlem said to the world. 'He tells me we've been screwed.'
'We've been screwed, sir. We need Breach. How the hell are we supposed to do this? Someone somewhere is trying to freeze this where it stands.'
'We've been screwed, he tells me, and I note he tells me so as if I am disagreeing with him. Which when last I looked I was not doing.'"
I enjoyed China's word-play, particularly 'grosstopically,' reference to things that are near in physical space but from different nations But the word-smithing didn't feel as sophisticated as Embassytown or as fun as Kraken, which is interesting, as they were published in a three-year span. Most of the vocabulary was created around the idea of 'unseeing' the neighbor city and it's occupants. Overall, the language felt stilted and excessively formal for genre fiction, further distancing me from the story.
It's not that I don't understand the exploration of the dissonant, conjoined cities. We take the noir detective format, incorporate a nice play on the idea of two cities, merged but unseen, occupying almost the same space with each other. It's actually a relatively common exercise in the spec-fic/sci-fi world, giving an author (and reader) familiar concepts to latch onto while the author forays into stranger places. There are times the Big Idea works well and can carry a novel on its own, but for me, this wasn't it. I'd suggest Only Forward if you want to play with the idea of city and identity.
chrisblocker librarything | 3.0 out of 5
The City & The City: A Review in Three Parts
Part I – CSI: Beszél
I picked up The City & The City because I've been trying to explore genres lately. Here was an author, highly spoken of, whose novel was part sci-fi, part fantasy. I had high hopes.
What I found when I opened The City & The City was a novel that was neither sci-fi or fantasy, but a completely different genre: the mystery; the whodunit; the one I avoid like no other. The City & The City is the story of a crime and the officers who solve it. It is bogged down by reports and interrogations, speculations and accusations; and if that's your sort of thing, you may enjoy this novel despite the fantastic elements. Personally, I didn't enjoy this first part. There was such a small sprinkling of anything but mystery that I wondered if I'd be able to make it through. Then a miraculous thing happened: the mystery took a back seat.
Part II – Murakami's 1984
The novel's mystery stepped aside and let the story's more paranormal elements run along side-by-side. It was one part Murakami with its dual cities in the same space, its portals from one “world” into the other; and it was one part Orwell, with its “unseeing” and Big Brother-like Breach. Now, if you've been following my reviews long, you probably know I despise 1984, but that has more to do with the fact Orwell didn't write it well than the story itself, so that's irrelevant in this case. Miéville can pull it off. He builds a world that is interesting and show more leaves me feeling paranoid. I loved this world. And though the focus was still the mystery, and this alienated me some, I was mostly drawn in.
Part III – Chaos
In the final third of the novel, The City & The City descends into madness. Chases, gunshots, secret agents, yelling, screaming, more accusations, more gunshots, more interrogations. It was too much action too fast for my little brain to process. Throw in the jumping between the cities, Beszél and Ul Qoma, and it was difficult to know what was going on. Perhaps if I'd acquainted myself with Miéville's writing style prior to this novel I would've been able to follow it more closely, but I found The City & The City to be confusing, especially in this final act.
Coda – Game Over, Play Again?
This was the wrong choice for me to start with. It's obvious Miéville has talent in storytelling and world-building, but this was simply too much mystery and action for me. It's one I'd recommend for fans of Miéville, and possibly for open-minded mystery readers, but for the rest of us, it's probably not a great place to start. Embassytown sounds more like my speed, and next time I want to make a journey into one of Miéville's worlds, I think this is the one I'll chose.
KayDekker librarything | 5.0 out of 5
There are times when I wish that I had a supply of special rating stars for extra merit, and now is one of those times. I've rated quite a few books at five stars before; the only previous candidate for one of those special stars that I've reviewed here was Boris Akunin's "Pelagia and the Red Rooster". The Akunin (read it!) would get its star for a dédouement so outrageous that a lesser author could not have carried it off; the Miéville would receive its star for its core conceit, which I simply must not spoil for you even by hinting at it, and for a luminous quality of prose that never betrays the conceit by seeming merely scaffolding for the support of a splendid idea.
If I had written this book, I could die happy.
Eyejaybee librarything | 4.0 out of 5
Divided cities have always captured the attention. There are those split by a river such as Buda and Pest, Minneapolis and St Paul, or (perhaps on a less globally significant scale) Huntingdon and Godmanchester. Then there is the additional poignancy of those cities subjected to political or religious division such as Jerusalem or Berlin, which has offered great scope to the novelist. The initial scenes of 'The Spy Who Came in From the Cold', centred on one of the bleak checkpoints in the Berlin Wall, encapsulate the grimness of the Cold War and allows John le Carre to deliver one of the most gripping openings of a spy novel.
'The City and The City' is a dazzling and unusual story, gives the idea of divided cities an additional twist., being set in the twinned cities of Beszel and Ul Qoma. These cities are merged - neither split artifically like East and West Berlin, nor by a river like Buda and Pest. Instead, both cities occupy the same physical space but, essentially but through the acquiescence of both populations (reinforced by the threat of severe compliance action at the hands of a clandestine force known as "Breach)", they are perceived as two different and separate cities. Indeed, each city is its own, separate city state, with its own government and foreign policy (Ul Qoma being the more prosperous), and passports and visas are required for legal movement between the two of them. As a consequence, although aspects of each city are constantly potentially visible to show more residents of either city, they all follow a policy of 'unseeing', in which they consciously fail to notice characteristics of the other city.
For each set of citizens any street or building falls within one of three possible classes: total, alter or crosshatch. "Total" buildings or streets are wholly within their own city; "alter" ones are wholly within the other city, and consequently not to be recognised or acknowledged; "crosshatch" areas lie within both cities and are accessible to the residents of both, though Besz citizens will deliberately "unsee" their Ul Qoman counterparts (and vice versa). "Unseeing" is relaxed to the extent that while driving through crosshatched streets the residents of both cities are capable of avoiding accidents with vehicles from the other city. But that is as far as it goes, legally. While no physical barriers exist, few people from either city are tempted to cross from one domain to the other because of their fear of the punitive measures that might be taken by Breach, the secretive body that polices the borders.
This all sounds seriously complicated, but it is amazing how quickly the reader accepts this background, and gets sucked into the plot which revolves around the investigation into the murder of an American archeology student, Mahalia Geary, who had been researching some of the deep-rooted political sensitivities within both cities (each of which has its extreme nationalist tendencies but also committed movements seeking formal unification). Inspector Tyador Borlu leads the investigation within Beszel but soon runs into unexpected obstruction from senior local politicians from both the nationalist and unificationist camps.
This novel works very well both as a straight detective story and also as a dystopian exercise (I don't think that "science fiction" is an appropriate term as all the technology involved is entirely contemporary). Mieville is particularly deft at offering little touches to add verisimilitude, and it is a long time since I have read anything as imaginative.
tungsten_peerts librarything | 4.5 out of 5
I share some feelings with other reviewers: the characters (even -- or especially -- the narrator) are quick sketches and the story is really an old-fashioned police procedural.
But the setting ...! The setting, or more specifically how Mieville introduces, unfolds and presents it is a 100% breathtaking tour-de-force, and I am humbled by it. At first, I wasn't quite sure how the division between the cities 'worked', but I think that's intentional. Once I had fully embraced it I was stunned by its audacity, and its political aspects.
In the end I felt as I have with many of the novels of Richard Powers: huge intellectual thrill, but ultimately a rather cold affect. If I had felt deeply for the characters it might have been unbearable (as Perdido Street Station was at a few points). Do read this.