
Similar Books
JennyArch librarything | 4.0 out of 5
It's hard to say what made this book such an absorbing read; really, very little happened, and the most action-packed scenes were generally the shortest (e.g. the last 8 or so pages). Curiously, it reads like a love song to science fiction (and libraries!), but the book itself is fantasy, full of magic and fairies and ghosts.
Except for a brief preface, dated May 1, 1975, we meet the main character, Mor, when she's already installed at Arlinghurst, a boarding school in England, in September 1979. She has come to be there, we learn, after some major events: her twin sister's death after a fight with their mother, a madwoman/witch, Mor's running away, being stuck in a Children's Home, then being sent to live with her father and his three older sisters, none of whom she has ever met; they're the ones who send her to boarding school. She's not allowed to live with her beloved Grampar or Aunt Teg, who helped raise her.
At sports- and games-obsessed Arlinghurst, Mor gets good marks but has few friends; she has a bad leg from the same car crash that killed her sister, and her main joy in life is reading sci-fi novels. She has vowed not to do any magic other than protective magic, to keep her safe from her mother. Her life at Arlinghurst improves once she finds a sci-fi book group at the library in town, and some kindred souls (including both the school and the town librarian, and the gorgeous Wim) with whom to discuss books.
Throughout her journal entries, as she recounts daily show more life (school, book club, term breaks with Daniel and the aunts and back home in South Wales with Grampar and Auntie Teg and the fairies), she philosophizes about magic (which can make things have happened - Mor's primary concern is that she made the book club be her karass, and if she did that, then they aren't exercising their free will) and writes about the books she's reading, nearly all science fiction - LeGuin, Delany, Tiptree, Niven, Dick, and others.
Quotes
Dedication:
This is for all the libraries in the world,
and the librarians who sit there day after day
lending books to people.
And it was the landscape that formed us, that made us who we were as we grew in it, that affected everything. We thought we were living in a fantasy landscape when actually we were living in a science fictional one. (34)
It's amazing how large the things are that it's possible to overlook. (34)
There are some awful things in the world, it's true, but there are also some great books. (52)
Interlibrary loans are a wonder of the world and a glory of civilization. (59)
Class is entirely intangible, and the way it affects things isn't subject to scientific analysis, and it's not supposed to be real but it's pervasive and powerful. See; just like magic. (66)
"It's a lovely dream, but it would never work....Marx is like Plato, he has dreams that can't come true as long as people are people." (Daniel's father Sam to Mor, 77)
Sometimes I'm not sure whether I'm entirely human....I care more about the people in books that the people I see every day. (119)
Morally, magic is just indefensible. (142)
"Bibliotropic. Like sunflowers are heliotropic, they naturally turn towards the sun. We naturally turn towards the bookshop." (Hugh to Mor and Janine, 154)
Magic isn't inherently evil. But it does seem to be terribly bad for people. (Mor, after the ear-piercing incident with the Aunts at Christmas, 184)
And I thought all that was wasted, all that time....Except it wasn't wasted, because we remember it. Things need to be worth doing for themselves, not just for practice for some future time. (189)
Since she's been dead, I'd almost forgotten, or not forgotten, but not thought about her as her distinct self so much, more about the two of us together. I'd felt as if I'd been torn in half, but really it wasn't that, it was that she had been taken away. I didn't own her, and there were always differences, always, she was her own person and I'd known that when she was alive, but that had blurred in all the time since when she hadn't been there to defend her own rights. (197)
Doing is doing.
Does it mean that it doesn't matter if it's magic or not, anything you do has power and consequences and affects other people? Because that might well be the case, but I still think magic is different. (198)
"But sometimes healing hurts, had you thought of that?" (Sam to Mor, 226)
I know no other book that is so much like going on a journey. (Re: LOTR, 235)
-how interesting that what comes out as doing the best he could in a man looks like neglect in a woman. (Re: Prospero, 325)
Tiptree stories to look up: "The Girl Who Was Plugged In" and "Love is the Plan, the Plan is Death" (241)
There's no proving anything once magic gets involved. (Re: creating her "karass" (Vonnegut reference) by magic, 261)
If you love books enough, books will love you back. (300)
DabOfDarkness librarything | 5.0 out of 5
Set in the 1970s, this is Mori’s story. She and her twin sister grew up in Wales with a mum who dabbled in magic. They could talk to fairies and had little magics of their own. But their mother seeks greater power and an accident leaves Mori crippled and her twin gone. So Mori makes the hard but necessary choice to track down a father she’s never met. He’s quite surprised but takes on the challenge of raising a teenage girl. Mori finds herself in England at a boarding school, which is a completely foreign experience for her. So she dives further into her reading, devouring SFF novels by the dozens each month.
This tale is told through a series of journal entries and sometimes letters to her father. It felt like such a personal tale, as if Mori was writing to her lost twin sister and I was eaves dropping on the conversation. The story twined three elements together – the discussion of SFF novels (always a bonus!), bits of magic, and historical fiction. It really worked for me and I was so caught up in this book. I felt like Mori was a good friend by the end of it.
We also have some touches of mystery. For instance, it takes quite some time to find out how Mori was crippled and what happened to her sister (though the latter is a bit vague on the details). Then we have a smaller and much more common mystery of her father and how he met her mother and what the fall out was over. Lastly, there are the fairies themselves. For much of the novel, I was wondering if Mori was show more still caught up in a childhood game or if she could really see fairies and that magic was a real, tangible thing in this book (at least for her). I loved trying to catch her in some circumstance that would tell me for a certainty one way or the other. That moment doesn’t come until late in the book and having that bit of tension for the majority of the novel was a delicious tease.
Life at the boarding school is full of the teasing just about any new crippled kid on the block could expect to get. She’s got so much new to figure out, having come from a small Welsh town where everyone knows everyone. There’s some bullies I wouldn’t mind giving a nose tweak to and then there are some cool kids that do what they can to make her feel welcomed. In between terms, she has her father, a paternal grandfather, and a few aunties to get to know. Life in England is definitely different and there’s plenty of blunderings to share around. I really resonated with these aspects of the novel as I often moved as a kid and shared several of the same feelings as Mori.
The wonder of science fiction and fantasy literature is on grand display in this story. I loved all the talk about what made a story good or didn’t in Mori’s succinct few sentences. While I was born in the late 1970s, I had access to my dad’s SFF library growing up, so I recognized perhaps 3/4 of the novels referred to in this story, however, I had only read perhaps 1/3 of them. Reading this book definitely added some classic SFF novels to my TBR list. Mori will travel on multiple buses, slogging through foul weather on her cane in order to get to the library, post, or local book shop. I could totally relate.
This is one of those novels that makes me wish really hard that magic was alive and well in our world. In fact, this book almost makes me believe that if I keep looking, I will find it. As a coming of age novel, it rang true in many ways – the teasing, having to make adult decisions, going through the awkwardness of puberty. Toss in the mystery, the magic, the love of SFF literature, and you have quite the worthy read!
The Narration: Katherine Kellgren did a great job. She was the perfect voice for Mori. I loved her Welsh accent overlayed with Mori’s humor and wit. Kellgren performed other regional accents as required, making it a great narration. Her male voices were distinct and believable as well.
Treebeard_404 librarything | 4.0 out of 5
Some books I intentionally read slowly, savoring them. Some I want to devour quickly. I'm a quarter of the way into Among Others, and I want nothing more than to settle on the sofa with some tea or cocoa and just stay there until I have finished this so-far-engrossing tale.
Later...
Okay, that sentiment pretty much stuck with me through the whole book. Having been a science fiction-loving teen-ager in 1980 (when this story is set), there are so many nostalgic moments when Morwenna mentions the books she's reading. But just as engrossing is her personal tale, told through her diary entries. But I have to say (without getting too spoilery) the climax feels under-written. It is abrupt and not described in the same detail as the rest of the book. So in that regard, I feel a little cheated. But I still do not hesitate for a second to recommend this book.
Update 20180822, Audiobook edition. The audiobook is bril. As it is a first-person narration, the reader performs in a heavy Welsh accent. This may put some people off, but I found it brought the whole thing to vivid life. Still highly recommended.
wealhtheowwylfing librarything | 4.0 out of 5
One of Amy Poehler's rules for improvisation is "Don't start a scene where two people are talking about jumping out of a plane. Start the scene having already jumped."
Morwenna Phelps has already jumped. Her mother tried to take over the world, but she and her twin sister, Morgana prevented her. And it's only now, in the midst of the aftermath of their magical quest and all that they sacrificed to save the world, that the book begins. Mor has always been an imaginative, independent child; her childhood spent running around the wild areas of Wales and talking to fairies only exacerbated this. But now she can't run, she's not in Wales, and she's surrounded by the walls of a strict English boarding school. And somehow, Mor has to go on.
Mor is an incredible character, analytical almost to a fault, introspective, blindingly intelligent, not particularly socialized. Her story is one of grief, of not being understood and not fitting in, and not particularly wanting to fit in. It is the story of someone who loves and trusts stories so much more than she's able to love and trust most of the people in her life. It is a very specific tale about growing up in 1970s as a smart, bookish girl who can see fairies and has a mother who wants to destroy and a father who is a stranger, but it is also a much more general tale. More than any other book I've read, this is the story of growing up as a geek and as a girl. Details have changed, but a surprising number remain instantly show more recognizable, even to someone who grew up decades later in a distant country.
I loved this book. And to me, it is the perfect response to so much of the fantasy that I read as a child, wherein our world was mundane and colorless and needed to be escaped. Because in this story, stories are fabulous and fairies are real--and yet still, this physical, earthy world we live in, filled with unfair rules and oppression and exhaust fumes, is worth living in.
leslie.emery librarything | 3.0 out of 5
I enjoyed this book while I was reading it, but on the whole I was disappointed by it.
First, there were many parts of the story that never ended up leading anywhere. To some extent I think this is a result of the journal format, but the author sticks to the idea of a realistic journal a little too closely sometimes. The most notable example of an unresolved story line is the suggestion of an attempt at molestation by Daniel. This incident is completely dropped and it's far too serious a topic to be a throwaway bit here. It's also concerning that Daniel ends up with a heroic role at the end of things given this.
But the thing that really made this book less enjoyable for me was the constant discussion of classic SF and fantasy books. To me it feels like this book is only written for fans who attend WorldCon and have already read all of the classics. I don't think it's reasonable to expect readers to have read most of the books that are discussed, especially since the genre is so much larger than it once was. This really alienated me, even though many of the main character's experiences resonated with me - reading a library's SFF section alphabetically, being better with books than with people, etc. As a person who was never lucky enough to find an SFF book club or many people who share this interest with me, I felt excluded by this book, and it seems likely many younger fans will as well.
I read this book because I've been reading the list of books that have won both the show more Hugo and the Nebula awards, and it was a disappointing entry in that list.