
Similar Books
Assassin's Apprentice
Before they are hanged
Coraline
Last Argument of Kings
The Yiddish Policemen's Unionhumouress librarything | 5.0 out of 5
I picked this up from the library after seeing lots of rave reviews of the series on LT, for which I thank everyone who mentioned it. I have to agree; this is a great book!
This is the first book in the Temeraire series, and it introduces us to Captain William Laurence, a lieutenant in his majesty's navy at the time that Britain was trying to prevent Napoleon invading. It is, however, an alternate history, in which there are dragons. There are not many, so the animals are valuable, but the men who handle them (aviators) are considered the lowest branch of the armed forces. The book is divided into three parts; the first part introduces us to Laurence, fast rising in the navy - until he inadvertently finds himself in harness to a dragon, to whom he gives the name Temeraire. The second part is about the training that Laurence and Temeraire undergo and how they integrate themselves into their new lives as aviator and dragon, and the third part sees them going to war in defence of the realm.
Almost any dragon books written now, I find, will give a nod (unconscious or otherwise) to Anne McCaffery's dragons of Pern; Novik's dragons only have one captain at a time (for the lifetime of that captain), to whom they give their utmost devotion - even through neglect and ill-treatment. However, her dragons are longer-lived than humans, so they will accept a new captain when the present one dies, often one from the same family. They are also much larger than Pernese dragons, who only show more have one rider (though they can carry several people). Each dragon is, effectively, an air-ship; apart from the captain, they have riflemen, lookouts, signalmen and crew-members on board who are responsible for the weight distribution on the dragon and first-aid in the air.
Temeraire was captured in the egg from the French, and as he is an unknown breed, he and Laurence explore his full potential together. He is highly intelligent (unlike some other dragon breeds) and insatiably curious, as well as dextrous in the air, and as a mid to heavy weight dragon, a valuable fighter. Laurence, a younger son of a lord, is a dedicated naval officer in a career that is just barely respectable in his father's eyes. By doing his duty and reluctantly harnessing a dragon, he has fallen even further and given up all career prospects; but he finds unexpected recompense in joining the Corps and in his relationship with Temeraire.
I found this a compelling story, full of action and easy to read ... very easy to find myself still reading, long past my bedtime. For all that he's as big as a sailing ship of the time, as a dragonet harnessed to Laurence, at times Temeraire reminded me of my children who are growing up and finding their way in the world.
This is a very well written book, with a lot of attention to language. The first part of the novel compares well against Jane Austen and Louisa May Alcott; if it weren't for the dragons, it would be easy to believe, from the language and the behaviour of the characters, that it had been written in the time it is set. Of contemporary books that try to do this, this is the only one I've read that works. However, in the second part, some characters are written more in P.G. Wodehouse-style, and by the third part it flows between Austen-type English and straight description in modern American; but this is merely an observation of mine, and not a criticism.
I've enjoyed this story so thoroughly, I'm giving it 5 stars, and going out to get more.
N.B. (further to my Google research). Laurence named Temeraire (meaning 'bold') after a ship of the Royal Navy. 'The Fighting Temeraire' defended Nelson's ship, HMS Victory, at Trafalgar and was itself named after Third Rate HMS Téméraire, which had been captured from the French and retained its name. Rather appropriate!
BrielM librarything | 2.0 out of 5
Perhaps I'm simply over sensitive but I found this book disturbing. First you have the dragons, who are not human, but definitely sentient. They don't seem to possess any loyalty or ideals related to king and country, they serve out of an almost slavish love for their captains. They are bred, mistreated, held captive, and "broken to harness". Then, with great pain and suffering, the are made to fight for the ideals that their unquestioning captains possess.
I couldn't stomach it. It's sort of if a battle were written from the POV of the cavalry horse, and for me, it bears a parallel to dog-fighting. Found it morally disgusting.
MeganDawn librarything | 5.0 out of 5
(Re-posted from http://theturnedbrain.blogspot.com)
Does this book have its flaws? Sure, in the same way a beautiful summer’s day has flaws. Oh no, I’m a little sweaty and it’s making my hair stick to my neck. Oh dear, my hand is sticky because my ice cream is melting on it. If things like these are enough to spoil summer days for you, then perhaps you’re from some alternate universe where most days are perfect in every single way. Likewise, if the flaws to be found in Temeraire (or Her Majesty’s Dragon if you live in other parts of the world) are enough to ruin the book for you them you must be accustomed to some truly spectacular books, and I envy you.
Truly, I can not remember the last time I encountered a book that was so much fun to read. Naval hotshot Laurence finds a dragon egg, and when it hatches the baby dragon, Temeraire, latches onto to him. (Think imprinting ala Twilight, but with a bazillion percent less creepy lameness). Laurence is yanked from the navy and sent to the Dragon corps where he and Temeraire learn to fight crime- er, I mean Napoleon. Enjoying this book was effortless. And yes, sometimes when something requires effort you end up loving it all the more intensely (like my oft mentioned favourite House of Leaves), but sometimes you just want to enjoy something without having to try.
And all this talk of Temeraire being easy to read is not a slight against the book, although I can how you might read it as such. You might be picturing show more characters who are little more than archetypes, short hand stand in for familiar tropes that we know so well we don’t have to guess at their motivations. Perhaps you think the plot is so obvious one barely needs to read the words to know what will happen next.
Wrong! Our hero Laurence is a complex fellow, and not always one hundred percent likable. He’s not a twenty first century man wandering around the seventeen hundreds like many characters in historical fiction seem to be, he is entirely true to the time period (or how I imagine the time period, as truly I am no expert). He is a stuffy and a stickler for rank, he balks at the idea of women in the workforce and heaven help anyone who doesn’t address him with enough respect. But he’s a good man and a fine leader, strict but fair and all that. And it doesn’t hurt that I suspect he’s rather dashingly handsome.
The plot itself, while nothing groundbreaking is certainly not predictable. While you’re always pretty sure that Laurence and Temeraire will come out ok (because there’s like thirty more books in this series) there are moments of genuine concern for the well being of other characters. Admittedly nothing much seems to happen for a great part of the book, it’s mostly Laurence and Temeraire getting to know each other, kind of like the pilot episode of a sitcom. I suspect Novik knew she would be writing more books in this series, and so saw no need to rush things. In the final quarter however things really go mad, with some nicely foreshadowed plot developments playing out and some pretty crazy dragon v dragon air battles. (Novik really excels as concise, clear and exciting battle descriptions, with is a rare skill that should always be valued).
The only real complaint I can lay against this book is the dragon Temeraire seems just a shade too perfect. He’s the rarest most uniquest most bestest dragon in all the world that can do things no other dragon can, and more! But you know what, I’m gonna let that go to. Reading the exploits of super awesome Temeraire reminds me a lot of the unabashed joy in the scene in the first Harry Potter book where Harry flies for the first time. There can be something really enjoyable in watching a character excel, and with his occasional petulance and revolutionary leanings Temeraire isn’t entirely perfect.
Not entirely perfect is true for the book as a whole really, but you can be damn sure that I await the further adventures of Laurence and Temeraire most eagerly, and I’ll let you know if installment two is as much fun as this one.
Puck goodreads | 4.0 out of 5
"Temeraire", a.k.a. The Gentleman’s Guide to How to Train Your Dragon.
Dragons! Who doesn’t love dragons? GOT Season 7 is finally bringing theirs into action, and so I decided to read this ‘old’ (= 10 years) dragon book, which I enjoyed immensely. The writing may be a bit dense, but reading about Laurence raising a baby dragon from egg to powerful beast was a lot of fun.
The plot is quite simple: we’re talking about Europe during the 17th century, but dragons are alive and flying and mainly being used as powerful weapons in the war. After taking commando over a French ship, Navy Captain Will Laurence discovers that it was carrying aboard a dragon egg that’s about to hatch. When it does, the dragon unfortunately imprints itself on Laurence, who now has to say goodbye to his old comfortable lifestyle to become a dragon trainer.
If you don’t see the problem here – me neither, because that job sounds AWESOME! And to be fair, Laurence doesn’t cry about his new career for too long, because Temeraire is the most incredible and endearing dragon I’ve met. He’s a mix between a curious young kitten (who loves gold necklaces as much as a cat loves yarn), but hyper-intelligent at the same time. And after Laurence and Temeraire move to the training grounds in Scotland, the reader gets to meet many more dragons and trainers, who all make this story much more engaging and delightful.
However, the setting and the writing-style can be an issue. As I said earlier the Napoleonic Wars provide the backdrop to this story, so a large part of the book is dedicated to talking about battle-strategies and the technical aspects of aerial training dragons. This information is interesting but a bit dull, and since we only get two real battle-scenes, some readers might find this book quite underwhelming when it comes to action.
The writing-style is also pretty old-fashioned. Similar to the writing in the books of Jane Austen*, almost every person that we meet is wealthy, well mannered and speaks ‘posh’. Luckily though the writing never becomes too wooly: dragons like honesty more than being polite, which takes fancy Laurence some getting used to. ;)
Because no matter the writing-style or the technical battle-plans: the relationship between Laurence and Temeraire's is easily the best part of this book. The way the two grow closer and mature, both separately and together, is well-build up and so touching.
Next to that Novik has done an amazing job with the historical worldbuilding (you wouldn't think adding dragons to the Napoleonic Wars would work, but it does), so I’m very excited to continue on with this series. Moar dragons, please!
* = speaking about Jane Austen: do you know that on the fanfiction-website Archive of Our Own, you can find a lot of Temeraire/Persuasion or Temeraire/Pride & Prejudice crossovers? #NoShame guys, reading about Elizabeth Bennet on a dragon is a great way to spend your afternoon.
Read here my other reviews of the Temeraire books:
#2 Throne of Jade (upcoming)
Katrana librarything | 4.0 out of 5
This book was an absolute guilty pleasure. A quick read; I found myself itching to pull it out at every opportunity and breezing through it.
The dialogue was crisp, the setting unique and rich, and the relationship between several characters namely Laurence, Temeraire, Levitas and Rankin had me invested... even brought a tear to my eye.
I did, sadly, find the writing lacking. The whiplash fast pace of the narration came at the expense of exposition. The lack of physical descriptions turned most characters into caricatures (by about halfway through the book I was resigned to the mental image of Temeraire as 'Toothless' the cartoon dragon).
This book left me craving more depth that I doubt I will find in the rest of the series, but I may seek it out when I'm looking for a palette cleanser.