
Similar Books
nkmunn librarything | 4.0 out of 5
This was an excellent fantasy that explored men and women's cultural responses to revenge, loyalty and love.
Jon_Hansen librarything | 5.0 out of 5
A great read. Nice to see a doorstopper fantasy with some ambiguities to the characters, but not so much to be all grim-n-gritty.
Foxen librarything | 4.0 out of 5
This was... difficult to sum up in one word. Here are a few words that were possible: long, epic, verbose, good, complicated. Part of my reaction to this book is because I read it aloud to my boyfriend. I do not recommend this one as a read-aloud. A lot of the detail is lost for the person being read to. It becomes difficult to keep track of names when you can't see them written down, and switches of perspective are often denoted just by section break (we had a lot of conversations like this: me: "ok, new section... *starts reading*", bf: "wait, where are we?", me: "you're not supposed to know yet. *continues reading*", bf: "so, what's going on?", me: "ok, well I glanced ahead and saw Dianora's name, and *commence plot summary of previous Dianora section (probably 100 pages ago)*".) This is a complicated fantasy novel with lots of different characters and story arcs and I think it just works better for keeping it straight in your head if you can go at your own pace and read it yourself- you get a better sense of the overall structure.
That aside, the book was very good, but wouldn't have suffered from a harsher editor. It is fantasy on the epic scale of the kind that I haven't read any of since high school. Twenty years ago the Peninsula of the Palm was taken over by two invading sorcerers, one from the east and one from the west, the native provinces were subjugated, and since that time the peninsula has been split in half, power balanced precariously but staticly between show more the two invaders. The province that fought the hardest, Tigana, was responsible for the death of the son of Brandin of Ygraith, the sorcerer from the west, and was punished severely in the aftermath. All memory of Tigana's heritage, culture, and name was removed by magic. Only those who had lived there before the spell was cast could remember Tigana, and to everyone else it became Lower Corte, the most oppressed province, and even the ability to hear the name "Tigana" was removed. The book is the story of the quest of various characters, primarily from Tigana, to restore Tigana's memory, rid the Palm of the invading sorcerers, and unite the provinces which were previously always divided by petty wars.
The plot is full of intrigue, the characters are well developed, and the ending is fantastic. No spoilers, but the twist (not really a twist... the unexpected development) at the end was the best kind: completely unanticipated, and yet it fit perfectly and had been anticipated in previous scenes that became quite chilling in retrospect. Even prior to the twist the ending was exactly what it should have been (it's always so satisfying when that's done right), and I didn't even anticipate the overall strategy until it was revealed. (wow, that's hard to describe without spoilers). The biggest strength of this novel is in its portrayal of good and evil, I think. All of the characters are complex, even the minor ones, and nothing is as straightforward as it at first seems. There are definitely characters that are purely forces for good in the world (though they have their own dilemmas, as well), but the villains are well done, three dimensional characters instead of the cardboard cutouts of evil that made me drop this genre in the 10th grade. Everyone does everything for a reason, psychological or real, and you really get a sense of the forces at work that make things play out the way that they do. Add to that a cast of realistic background characters, and you have a quite good story.
My only complaint with this book is in the writing, and this is where my comment about a good editor comes in. The book is long, and the length is primarily the florid, epic musings of the author. I understand what he's going for- the epic, tragic feel, and particularly the poignancy of lost Tigana- but really it was a bit too much. Such a feel has to be created with emotion, not just long sentences, and at the beginning particularly it felt unearned. Given that the only real action of the book is in the last 100 or so pages, the verbosity of various characters' lamentations and angst in the first 500 pages sometimes just obscured their own sense of purpose and came across as whiny.
So, yes, a thoroughly 4 star book, based on very tangible positives (characters, plot, ending, also somewhat the world-building) and tangible negatives (the writing). Recommended, but only if you're definitely in the mood for it, and be willing to put it down if you're getting tired of it. Do finish it, though, eventually- it's worth it.
alwright1 librarything | 3.0 out of 5
Usually you can give me a set of likable, oppressed rebels, and you can pretty much automatically sign me up for the revolution. The kinds of heroes who fight for freedom in these stories were always celebrated in my home, in the kinds of media my family was excited about. I liked the characters in Tigana well enough, but some of the actions that they took in their fight for freedom made me question whether I would be that resolved. So I was surprised to survey myself, and then realize that I had never before surveyed myself, as to whether killing individuals, say a man guarding a barn, in the name of some political setup for the promotion of "freedom," is something I value or am capable of. Surprising thing not to have really considered before...
The curse that one of the oppressors puts on a city in the book of taking its name and identity is an interesting one. And the theme of identity for the individual characters from the city throughout was good to follow. I wasn't thrilled with the magic system, since it wasn't explained or terribly intuitive, just kind of mysterious, even though there were several sorcerer characters. Anyway, an enjoyable enough read.
-Eva- librarything | 4.0 out of 5
Epic fantasy about a group of Tigana natives plotting to overthrow the sorcerer who has caused their beloved land to be forgotten. This is my first, but not last, book by Guy Gavriel Kay since I became really fond of his style during this read; his world-building really works for me in that he never comes outright and explains how things work, but just works it subtly into the story so that the reader feels part of the world. His language is also so lovely - he does know how to weave a beautiful sentence. Along with the great world-building, Kay also inhabits his world with intriguing, flawed characters who make mistakes but have big hearts and I have to admit to shedding a little tear now and again for them. Long, but thoroughly enjoyable read.