
Similar Books
The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
Under the Dome
Ancillary Mercy
A Wizard of Earthsea
Perdido Street StationMeganDawn librarything | 3.0 out of 5
(cross posted from http://theturnedbrain.blogspot.com.au/)
A chapter into this book and I was rapt. I could see what all the hype was about and I was kicking myself for waiting so long to start reading it. But somewhere around the middle these positive feelings started to wane, and by the end I found myself unimpressed. I don’t think I’ve ever had how I felt about a book change so much while reading it!
What captured me at first with this book was the structure of it. I liked the way the way Yeine’s version of events kept getting interrupted by a mysterious other voice. One of my favourite narrative techniques is the unreliable narrator, and this other voice disagreeing with Yeine’s telling hinted that we were only getting one version of a much bigger story.
I also really liked the idea of the novel. For such a firm atheist, I’m hugely fond of gods as actual characters in fiction- chained ones even more so. God of night, Nahadoth, faced off against his brother and sun god, Itempas, and lost. As punishment he and the lesser gods who supported him have been forced to serve a single family for hundreds of years. As a result this one family has grown disproportionately powerful and rules over all the other kingdoms who don’t conveniently have enslaved gods to do their bidding.
The character of Nahadoth was fantastically done, in my opinion. The trouble with gods as characters is that it can be hard to make them seem sufficiently godlike. Too often they come across as show more just really powerful and capricious humans. Not so here. There’s something wholly alien and terrifying about Nahadoth. A god he may be, but he has also been a slave for centuries and I really liked how Jemisin portrayed the effect this had upon him. He also reminded me a lot of one of my all time favourite characters; Neil Gaiman's Morpheus. If Morpheus has been trapped in that circle for two thousand years instead of twenty I feel he might have ended up damaged and dangerous in much the same way as Nahadoth.
And Nahadoth wasn’t even the best of Jemisin’s god filled cast. Nahadoth's son and fellow slave Sieh was far and away my favourite. He was made in the image of a child and has remained so for centuries, although it’s never made clear whether or not that’s by choice or design. There’s there fantastic tension in him, between childlike innocence and the wisdom (and despair) of the ages he’s lived through. Certainly Sieh was the most complicated character in the book, and I would liked to have seen more of him.
Instead I had to slog through pages of Yeine. If Nahadoth and Sieh were rich, complex wines then Yeine was water. There was just nothing to her. No personality, no initiative, no spark. My decreasing satisfaction with this book can be wholly attributed to her. The entire plot of this book consists of Yeine going where other characters tell her to go, and doing what other character tell her to do. The other characters plot and scheme and act, she spends a lot of time hanging out in her room.
She was the leader of her people, a fiercely matriarchal society, but you would never guess either of those things from the way she acts. Leadership skills? Tactical thinking? Diplomacy? None in evidence. If she escapes danger its only because another character helps her, if she guesses at someone's motives it’s only because another character pretty much had to tell her. The book couldn’t have happened without her there, but in the same way that Raiders of the Lost Arc couldn’t have happened without the arc, or the last Harry Potter book wouldn’t have gone far without the Horcruxes. Yeine is a glorified McGuffin, an object to be moved around and used by the other far more interesting characters who make up A Hundred Thousand Kingdoms.
The plight of Nahadoth, Sieh and the other god’s was engaging enough to keep me reading, and Jemisin does present an interesting take on ideas of sexuality and power. But Yeine’s character was so poorly done that it dragged down the whole book, and will probably stop me from ever picking up the sequel.
Liesl. librarything | 5.0 out of 5
Okay, I thought this was gonna be some high-fantasy book with 0 romance… safe to say I was wrong. Most of the time I don’t really like romantasy because the romance takes over and there’s not much fantasy left. But in this book it was absolutely perfectly executed. Now bcs I didn’t expect it I lowkey started blushing at some parts of this book (maybe shouldn’t’ve on the train). I love the lore and the religion and I just love reading about the complex concepts. This book enchanted me and I read it in less than three days, it was amazing. Now, if I remember correctly the next book won’t have Yeine as a main character anymore (which I am actually so sad about because I loved her as a character, also might be wrong, still have to check it out) but I can’t wait to continue and explore more of nk jemisin’s writing
ImperfectCJ librarything | 4.0 out of 5
This was a very interesting book to read so soon after Neil Gaiman's American Gods. It certainly takes a different direction, but both have to do with gods interacting with humans and showing their all-too-human foibles.
My husband picked this one up for me after hearing it praised on NPR as a fantasy novel outside the boys' club tradition of the genre. I found the book an absolute pleasure to read. It's fantasy but with an almost sci-fi feel to it, as most of the action takes place in the palace where the main characters are all essentially imprisoned (to one degree or another). It put me in mind of the "trapped on a space ship" motif.
In some areas, I found the text to be a little repetitious (how many times do I need to read, in detail, about the shadows in Nahadoth's face?), but it was a smooth read despite these. I found it highly enjoyable to read Yeine's evolution. Surrounded by immortals for whom change occurs on the scale of eons, and a rigid, orderly society intent upon keeping things the same, the changes in Yeine are all the more striking.
Jemisin's world was vivid and clear in my mind. Unlike with many fantasy/sci-fi novels, I didn't find myself getting disoriented in an unfamiliar landscape, which I think speaks to her writing skill. I really appreciated that this was a fantasy novel in which women and people of color took a lead role and that was just the way of Jemisin's world. There was no beating the reader over the head, no "Look how cool! A culture of show more women warriors! Gods whose skin isn't pale!" It was just a good story and these were just the characters who populated it.
Oh, and without being lewd or clumsy, the steamy parts were oh-so-steamy! The close relationship between hatred and lust, control and the lack thereof, was quite effective.
This book kept me up past my bedtime and then made the kids and me late for our morning activities because I couldn't put the darned thing down, but it was worth it. I just wish the cover art on the paperback edition were a little less...I don't know, in line with the genre? I found myself feeling self-conscious reading it in public. Plus, Yeine had short hair. What's with the flowing locks? Unless that's supposed to be Nahadoth (in which case, what's he doing on the cover?)
Adamantium librarything | No Rating
I'm surprised by how much more mature/technically accomplished Jemisin's "The Fifth Season" was, but something vulnerable and personal at the heart of this was compelling. I have to say I'm not feeling compelled to read the rest of the trilogy anytime soon--the first book is fairly self-contained, and the follow-up would be an ffx-2 situation (I hope this is the first time anyone has ever used this comparison).
thenightbookmobile librarything | 3.5 out of 5
N.K. Jemisin is definitely a force to be reckoned with in the fantasy genre. Her ability to craft an exciting and imaginative fantasy world is evident from the very first. The story of the gods is both unique and unpredictable. I would venture to say it is the most original use of gods in a story that I have ever seen. Jemisin's gods are everything you would imagine a god to be. They do not get weighed down by humanity because they are not human. I think this is one of the book's greatest strengths.
Another credit to Jemisin, and perhaps the biggest one, is her ability to write. This woman can write the pants off of many fantasy writers and many writers in general. Her phrases are lyrical and raw and inspiring. I immediately wanted to write them down and share them with others. The stream of consciousness style of writing was the novel's greatest strength and its greatest weakness. I thought it was strongest when Yeine's narrative was being overtaken by Enefa.
“I gather her body to mine and will all of creation to make her live again. We are not built for death. But nothing changes, nothing changes, there was a hell that I built long ago and it was a place where everything remained the same forever because I could imagine nothing more horrific, and now I am there
Then others come, our children, and all react with equal horror
in a child’s eyes, a mother is god
but I can see nothing of their grief through the black mist of my own. I lay her body down but my hands are show more covered in her blood, our blood, sister lover pupil teacher friend otherself, and when I lift my head to scream out my fury, a million stars turn black and die. No one can see them, but they are my tears.”
I also found the stream of consciousness style to be frustrating and melodramatic at times. Yeine would often begin a story only to swear she'd come back to it later and start telling another one. While it certainly was a unique way to tell the story, it was also very distracting, and confusing for me as a reader.
While I think that this novel was beautifully crafted, and such an original addition to the fantasy genre, I didn't absolutely love it. In fact, I found myself uncaring about the outcome and the fates of the characters and the plot. I think this is because the characters never felt relatable to me, and I couldn't say that I truly liked any of them. Sieh seems to be a favorite among readers but I thought he was actually a little creepy and unpredictable. I suppose that's as it should be, since he is a god, and they live their lives in shades of gray. I think that it was just hard for me to get outside of my own head and view the gods as non-human creatures who clearly don't play by our rules. If I had been able to do so his behavior would not have seemed so odd to me.
Yeine was my favorite but there was something about her that always kept the reader at a distance and didn't allow for intimacy. Perhaps it was because she was slipping away? Characters seem to make or break novels for me. If you can make me care deeply for at least one character then you've got me, but if you can't, then it's going to be hard to grab my attention much at all.
I'd definitely recommend this to fans of the fantasy genre looking for something worthwhile and unique.